No Stranger Than Love (2015)

Romantic comedy directed by Nick Wernham and starring Alison Brie, Justin Chatwin and Colin Hanks. A high-school teacher called Lucy Sherrington (Brie) attracts the attention of almost every man she encounters, but she is not interested, holding out for what she hopes will be her true love. Before long, she thinks she has found just that in one Clint Coburn (Hanks), a married sports coach. But she becomes unsure if their relationship truly is one driven by love, or if it is simply motivated by lust. So Clint declares that they will not have sex until Lucy tells him that she loves him. However, just as Lucy might be about to do so, a hole suddenly appears in the floor and Clint is gone. A man named Rydell White (Chatwin) appears to help find Clint, and Lucy has another prospective true love to trouble over.